Saturday, April 01, 2006

Faking Places - April Fools

Blatently stolen from Project for Public Spaces
Sorry, it was too funny.

Please check out the more serious matter on a regular basis. Lots of good information.


News and Ideas from Project for Public Spaces

Feature Story:


Congressmen enjoy a test run of the proposed Thursday potlucks on the National Mall.

National Mall to Become Lunchtime Hangout for Congress

With partisan tensions running high on Capitol Hill, it appears that both sides of the aisle can still manage to agree on one thing: Hanging out together on the National Mall for good food and friendly conversation.

[read the full article]

Also In This Issue:

New Self-Help Movement Transforms the Streets of America

Auto Addicts Anonymous credited with reviving community life. [read more...]

O Canada!

Placemaking sweeps the north country. [read more...]

Let 10,000 Plazas Bloom

Texas looks south for ideas to enliven its communities. [read more...]

PPS Names Best and Worst Public Spaces in the Galaxy

From universe-spanning wormholes to neighborhood asteroid belts, here are the best places we've come across. Plus, don't miss our Cosmic Hall of Shame. [read more...]

Torino Converts Olympic Spaces into Summertime La Dolce Vita

"Sure, it was easy to get people to come out in public in the dead of winter, but once the snow melts - what is there for them to do?" [read more...]

PPS Staffers Branch Out as Fashion Models for J. Crew

"It's sort of weird. I never envisioned myself as a fashion model." [read more...]

New York Round-up

Forest City Ratner drops arena proposal for Brooklyn's Atlantic Yards. Plus, New York's first Bike and Walk to Work Week, a surprising announcement from IKEA, and a change of plans for the Bronx Terminal Market. [read more...]

Introducing Sodpavers...

...the green alternative to wide swaths of asphalt. [read more...]

Past Issues of Faking Places:

April 1, 2005

Fearful of losing their long dominance of the streets, millions of autos staged massive park-ins in public spaces around the nation to protest pedestrians and alternative modes of transportation. [read more...]

April 1, 2004

Under the influence of PPS, Wal-Mart abandoned mega-stores in favor of locally-owned, downtown shops. [read more...]

Monday, March 27, 2006

Cavaliers are moving to Independence

This was just released by the Cavaliers on their web page.
Although it would have been nice to have some new construction in the place of a parking lot, it is encouraging to see Mayor Jackson's economic development cooperation talked about during the State of the City take shape already.
I am impressed.

Tax-sharing plan proposed that will allow Cleveland and Independence to share income tax revenue as Cavaliers move practices to Independence

Cleveland, Ohio, March 27, 2006 – Cleveland Mayor Frank G. Jackson and Independence Mayor Fred P. Ramos announced a plan today to split income tax revenue from the Cleveland Cavaliers payroll when the team begins practicing in Independence prior to the 2007-08 season. The announcement was made at a joint news conference in the Quicken Loans Arena with Cavaliers and Quicken Loans Arena CEO Mark Stornes.

Legislation will be introduced in both Cleveland and Independence that, when passed, will allow the cities to share revenue generated by the Cleveland Cavaliers’ payroll. The Cavs currently practice in the City of Cleveland at the Quicken Loans Arena, but plan to build a new facility in Independence.

Mayor Jackson, a long-time proponent of regional economic cooperation, says that this situation is a perfect example of how cities within the region can work together to boost the economy.

“We can and should encourage businesses to locate where it is in their best interest to do so, without stealing jobs and revenue from our neighbors,” said Mayor Jackson. “This revenue sharing strategy will allow the Cavs to build a new facility where it makes sense for them to do so and allow both Independence and Cleveland to reap the benefits. I thank Mayor Ramos for his efforts and willingness to work with the City of Cleveland, and the Cavaliers organization for their commitment to building success for Cleveland and the region.”

Mayor Ramos stated, "I applaud Mayor Jackson and his staff on initiating an early relationship built on trust and cooperation between our communities. We will work together, to the best of our abilities, on the Cavaliers project to benefit both our communities and the positive economic impact it will have on each. I also look forward to working with Mark Stornes and the Cavaliers organization to build and bring their practice facility to the City of Independence."

"The spirit of cooperation shown by Mayor Jackson and Mayor Ramos has been critical in placing the Cavaliers in a position to move forward with building the best practice facility in the NBA. They have been team players, while still representing their respective communities' interests well," said Cavaliers and Quicken Loans Arena CEO Mark Stornes. "The new Cavaliers practice facility will play a very important role in the continued development of the championship-caliber culture we are committed to having. We are thankful that Mayor Jackson and Mayor Ramos have been supportive in helping devise this win-win-win equation for Cleveland, Independence and the Cavaliers."

Both Cleveland City Council and Independence City Council will deliberate over the legislation. Mayor Jackson and Mayor Ramos are both optimistic that the legislation will pass and the revenue-sharing plan will move forward.

Saturday, March 25, 2006

Cleveland Planning Commission Report - Friday, March 17, 2006

Cleveland Planning Commission Report, March 17, 2006

Call to order – 9:04 AM

Roll Call –

Present:
Bob Brown
Joe Cimperman
Lillian Kuri
Gloria Jean Pinkney
David Bowen
Larry Lumpkin
Rev. S. Small

Absent:
Tony Coyne

Approved March 3rd minutes

Legislation (all passed)

Ordinance #311-06
Improvement of the Department of Finance facility, specifically the Print Shop portion of it, at 1735 Lakeside Avenue
Ordinance #376-06
Authorization for the Historic Warehouse District Development Corporation to encroach into the public right-of-way by installing hanging flower baskets on every historic light pole
Ordinance #xxx1-o6
Legislation to be introduced to allow a lease agreement between the city and Lake Shore Electric Railway to store a trolley collection inside the Dock 32 Warehouse for 18 months (introduced on March 20th).

They are currently working to raise funds for construction of a new storage and viewing at the end of the Waterfront near the Municipal Parking Lot.

Mark R (from Marous Brothers – I forget his last name): The cars have to be off of the Olmstead Falls property by mid-June or the current owner ill lose the trains to the new owner.

Jim Cox (Flats Industry Association, Executive Director):
Submitted letter to the Commission
“Today I am here to advocate for the ‘highest and best use’ for Dock 32 at the Port of Cleveland. Dock 32’s last tenant was FedMar Terminals, which paid $175,000 annually in rent as well as more than $100,000 in dockage and wharfage fees. FedMar handled 100,000 tons of cargo valued at $35 million.
The Port, through its Memorandum of Understanding with the previous administration, surrendered its lease of Dock 32. Returning the dock to the city so that the property would become an integral part of the City’s “Lakefront Plan.’
Using this invaluable dock wharf and warehouse space for the storage of trolleys, even if only or 18 months, is not the ‘highest and best use’ of this maritime infrastructure.
As the …Northeast Ohio Research Consortium’s Jan. 2006 Brief … indicates, the predominant workforce segment of the economy of Cleveland and Northeast Ohio is still manufacturing. To retain and reinforce that industry and the many jobs it generates, Flats Industry believes Dock 32 should be restored to the highest and best use, even if only for 18 months. It should not be another parking lot generating zero revenues for the city. Flats Industry believes Dock 32 should be restored to the highest and best use, for maritime activity, even for a minimum of 18 months.
Maritime use will guarantee jobs and will guarantee a substantial income to the city’s general fund. Thank you.”
Bob Brown:
The lease was terminated by the City with an understanding that there would be no problems

Mark:
The trolley will remain inside… there should be room on the outside of the warehouse for emergency storage.
There is a plan B that will utilize storage at a warehouse at Mitel Steel – not our first choice… would not be accessible to those who want to see the trains.

Jim Cox:
The Steel needs to be inside a warehouse, not outside.

Resolution #319-06
Declaring the necessity and intention to appropriate property for the public use of repairing and resurfacing a portion of St. Clair Avenue

Administrative Approvals (all passed)

Ordinance #300-06
Regarding the construction of maintenance yard wash-out pits

St. Clair/Superior BRD
1. The Year of the Dog – St. Clair/Superior neighborhood art installation project presentation. Previously passed by the commission - see here.
2. Lot Split – 3600 East 59th Street (tabled)

Design Review

1. DRC 06-017
East Woodland Estates-Hill Place Phase 1 Remodel (w/d)

2. DRC 06-018 (approved)
East 17th Street Extension, Streetscape Design
415’ of new roadway that will extend East 17th Street at Euclid south to Prospect Avenue. Construction will begin in April and will end in August. It is part of the Euclid Corridor Project. There will be ornamental fencing along the parking lots with appropriate landscaping.
Kuri: There is an opportunity to visually enhance the building to the East of the new road. (Bonfoey Gallery)
Brown: There are future plans to address the appearance of the Hanna Parking Garage by City Architecture.
Kuri voiced her displeasure with the standard streetlights that will be installed.
Brown: We will contact CPP about seeing what is available in the inventory that would be more suitable.
Design Review is suggesting the placement of trees along the sidewalk next Bonfoey – the Planning Commission disagrees.

3. DRC 06-016 (approved)
1000 St. Clair Avenue, The Liberty at St. Clair, Multifamily Supportive Housing
A joint development of EDEN, Inc. and the Cleveland Housing Network. It is a four story building located at 10000 St. Clair Avenue with 72 units ranging in size from 330 to 380 sq. ft. It is "supportive housing project for single adults in critical need of housing and in danger of being homeless." There will be a community space with kitchen, computer classrooms, multi-purpose living spaces, laundry room, case manager offices and 24-hour front desk security.
Project cost: $10,000,000
Architect: Weese Langley Weese
Construction to start in summer

4. DRC 06-013 (all but the the top of the building approved)
750 and 700 Huron Road, AT&T Buildings, Skyline and Street Level Building Identification Signs
Proposed signage with the new at&t logo or the two buildings on Huron Road. The only issue was with the logo at the top of the main building. The commission is not happy with the size and placement of the logo.
I did not have any renderings, but a little Photoshop magic can show you sort of what it would look like. (I did this in five minutes, so forgive the crudeness of it please.) The logo near the top floors of the building, in fron of the windows, is one of the proposals (without the white background and maybe twice the size)
By the end of the presentation, the commission, as well as the at&t representative all felt the best option would be to place the main logo sphere at the top of the building as is pictured in my simulation. This would give a nod to the whole superman Daily Planet concept that the building is rumored to have inspired. The rep was going to propose this to his bosses. (building photo courtesy of Clevelandskyscrapers.com)


Friday, March 24, 2006

Quicken Loans

I heard on the news this morning (according to the reporter) that Quicken Loans is looking for a new headquarters once their lease expires in Livonia, Detroit in a few years.

You can read the PD article here.

However, I looked around for some news in the Urban Ohio Forum and found a post that linked to two articles from the Detroit News, here and here, as well as a bunch more from Google news.

It is good to see the other side of the story.

For now, I am glad the new loan center will be opening soon.

Monday, March 20, 2006

Innerbelt news in Crain' Cleveland

Not the most informative aticle, but it ended like this:
Michael Armstrong, senior transportation engineer with the Federal Highway Administration’s Columbus office, said no decisions have been made on the Innerbelt. He said his office is expecting an environmental impact report from ODOT in November that will document the environmental, social and economic impact of the planned reconfiguration. It will open a public comment period and after that make a decision whether to adopt ODOT’s plan or ask the state to modify its plan. He wouldn’t put a timetable on the federal decision-making process.


Saturday, March 18, 2006

As if I have enough time!

I've had this feeling for a number of years now. The feeling that we are made to drive long distances in order to meet are basic needs. I have always lived in the city and it drives me crazy to have to go to the suburbs to purchase anything the family may need... or want. I don't mean to complain, I love driving. I enjoyed it my whole life - even as a cab driver. I just hate driving with other people on the road. Many people should not be allowed to drive. They should be made to renew their test every so many years - I would do it if I had to.
Any way... I just started another blogthat I want to use to document the things I see when I am driving (stopped... most of time).
Enjoy "View from the Dashboard."

I may at some point open the blog up to other drivers who want to post.

Saturday, March 11, 2006

Cleveland Planning Commission Report – Friday, March 3, 2006

Cleveland Planning Commission Report – Friday, March 3, 2006

Call to order – 9:12 AM

Roll Call –

Present:
Bob Brown
Tony Coyne
Joe Cimperman
Lillian Kuri
Gloria Jean Pinkney
David Bowen

Absent:
Larry Lumpkin
Rev. S. Small

Approved February 17th minutes

Zoning
Ordinance No 272-06: (approved)
Change the zoning on the southwest corner of Linnet Avenue and West 117th Street from General Retail Business District to a Multi-Family District.
City Planner, Michal Bosak and Councilwoman Dona Brady spoke on behalf of the project and the property owner directly affected spoke against it.
Brady:
This is a continuation of the Master Plan.
The rezoning has already been completed up to Governor.
There is a lack of parking for the business that are there now. Patrons are parking on the local side streets, blocking access to residents and the fire station in particular.
We think it would be a great place residential occupation. Especially with Halloran Park across the street.
The master plan is calling for West 117th Street to be all residential from Lorain Avenue to Bellaire Road.

Councilwoman Brady was expecting to introduce legislation for more zoning at the council meeting Monday, March 6. This will make land use more compatible with what is happening in the neighborhood. The proposed rezoning will run along the entire West 117th Street corridor from Lorain to Bellaire on both sides of the street. Of course, any properties that currently have business on them will be grandfathered in.

There was one person opposed to the rezoning. Mainly because he did not understand how this would impact his business. He owns a bar that is currently closed for renovations. As long as his bar reopens within at least six months, his business can remain.

Mandatory Referral
1. Ordinance No. 325-06: Authorizes the sale of Land Reutilization Program property located on Union Avenue to Kids Health 2020. APPROVED
(This is a Child and Family Welness Center. The Sommission stated that the title not be transferred until they see final drawings.)
(Photos courtesy of Alethea Ray, City of Cleveland)

2. Ordinance No. 164-06: Authorizes the sale of Land Reutilization Program property located on East 33rd Street and Cedar Avenue to Burton, Bell, Carr Development, Inc. (TABLED)
Summary Calendar (all approved)
1. Ordinance No. 1835-05: Authorizes the sale of Land Reutilization Program property located on East 49th Street to Scott Bibb.
2. Ordinance No. 193-06: Authorizes funding to rehabilitate parts of St. Clair Avenue between East 55th and 72nd Streets. {Interesting – this is in Councilman Cimperman’s ward and he was very surprised to hear about it… but happy nonetheless.}
Design Review
1. DRC 06-016: 10000 St. Clair, the Liberty at St. Clair, Multi-family Supportive Housing (withdrawn).
2. DRC 06-013: 750 Huron Road. AT&T Building. Skyline and Street Level Signs (withdrawn).
3. DRC 06-007: 811 Prospect Avenue, Fantasy One Night Club, Renovation and Signage.
The owners are asking for final approval for this property that used to be the site of the former Standard Theater. (approved)
From CinemaTreasures.org:
This downtown Cleveland theatre, which was sort of out of the way on Prospect Avenue, was mainly a venue for adult pornographic films, although it had shown mainstream films early in its life. The Standard closed in the mid-1980's. The theatre had shown black-oriented action films briefly in the early 1980's.
The building that exists there now has been empty ever since it was constructed in the mid 80’s The new nightclub/restaurant is expected to be open early during the week to feed business people and late night for club goers. (6:00 AM – 2:00 AM) There will be a video game arcade on the first floor and bar/nightclub on the second floor and mezzanine. The is to be decorative lighting on the outside that is to give the feeling of effervescence to those on the street.
Kuri suggested they test the lighting out first because the streetlights may drown out the special lighting, as is what happened with the lighting for Cleveland Public Art.

Fantasy One Night Club should be open by the middle of June.

Innerbelt Update:
James Haviland gave the Commission a briefing from the Community Meeting on Tuesday, February 21.

Some of the discussion from the update (everyone was talking and over-speaking each other, that I missed much of it)

Cimperman: Listening to ODOT was like watching FOX News – everything was like “TERROR AERT… TERROR ALERT”
Kuri: If the Economic Impact Study has 50% of the graphic detail as the accident graphics ODOT showed on the screen, we would have one heck of a report.
Cimperman: ODOT keeps telling us, “This is the most dangerous section of freeway in the state.” Of course what they do not say in the same sentence is that this one of he busiest sections of freeway in state as well.
Haviland: We found there are more severe accidents along the I480/I77 interchanges.
CSU is on board with ODOT, but we are not in concert.
Coyne: Doesn’t CSU gain more land in this deal?
EVERYONE: YES!!!
The conversation turned to the proposed ramp closure at Carnegie Avenue and how if the ramp is going to stay, the Juvenile Court House might have to go.
Cimperman: All of the sudden, ODOT has become the great defender of Historic Preservation
Coyne: The Courthouse is in the hands of the County Commissioners. If they put their foot down and make the judges move to the property in Fannie Lewis’s ward, the building could come down.
Haviland: Downtown Cleveland Alliance has now sent letters of concern to ODOT, Voinovich and many others. The Indians and the Cleveland Clinic are now seeing the problems that will occur with the eliminations of Carnegie and Prospect. They are beginning to make some noise.
We are hiring are own traffic engineer to do further studying.
Cimperman: I will go on record – If this plan is approved as currently stated, it will kill the city.
Coyne: We need to wrap this up for today, but let me add, we may be done with public input. We are going to have to lock some people in a room and not let them out until this is resolved.

Monday, March 06, 2006

Montreal's Mirabel Airport To Be Turned Into Theme Park

This is interesting. From AviationNow:

Montreal's Mirabel Airport, which hasn't seen a passenger flight since October 2004, will be transformed into an amusement park under a deal reached last week.

Aeroports de Montreal (ADM) and I-Parks-Oger International signed a memorandum of understanding to develop an "indoor recreational multiplex" at Mirabel covering more than 100,000 square meters. AeroDream, or Reveport in French, will be a "one-of-a-kind attraction in North America," targeting local visitors as well as tourists and business travelers.

The first phase of the project will cost C$100 million (US$87.6 million) and will be financed by private-sector and institutional funding. The facility will be built on the site of the abandoned passenger terminal. The complex will also include the administration building, parking facilities and the on-site hotel, which will be renovated. The hotel will be refurbished first and will serve as a showcase for the project. Work on the hotel is scheduled to begin by June with a fall completion target.

Conversion of the terminal is to start in the fall, with the hope of a phased opening by the end of 2007. The new park will have a giant aquarium, an indoor beach and movie theaters. The MOU calls for the consortium to sign a lease with an initial term of 25 years and two renewal options of five years each. A draft proposal has already been submitted to Transport Canada.

Mirabel opened in 1975 as a reliever airport for what is now called Trudeau Airport in Dorval. Few flights ever served Mirabel, however, and the last passenger flight landed in October 2004. The airport still has some cargo and general aviation flights.

Also found here:

French-led consortium signs on to build $300-million Rêveport recreation complex

The consortium is made up of I-Parks Creative Industries, a French firm that specializes in the creation of urban tourist attractions, and Oger International SA, the global engineering company owned by the family of slain former Lebanese prime minister and entrepreneur Rafik Hariri.
Here:
AeroDream, or Rêveport, is to be a year-round tropical park for locals and tourists alike, complete with 3-D movie screens under geodesic domes, a giant aquarium, a spa, an indoor beach and retail space.
And Here:
The sprawling facility some 40 kilometres north of Montreal was billed as the airport of the future when it was opened amid great fanfare in 1975. It cost $500 million at the time, including expropriation of dozens of farms. Passenger growth projections did not happen, so the airport authority and federal government took the controversial decision to converge all flights at Pierre Elliott Trudeau International Airport in suburban Dorval, more popular because of its proximity to the city. The last passenger traffic stopped at Mirabel in 2004, leaving only cargo and private flights.
Is this possible for Burke Lakefront Airport? Somebody contact the Cleveland Quarries people in Amherst.


Saturday, March 04, 2006

4600 Euclid Avenue

Reported in the February 3rd Planning Comission Report, there will soon be new construction a the site of a building that burned down during rehab. This is near the Agora Theater - right next door. These are a an elevation and a conceptual rendering of the building. Expect this conceptual to be pretty much right on, since Paul Volpe, et al, asked for final approval from the Commission.















(I keep forgetting to do this. Apologies) Photo Credits: City Architecture - 2006



Stay tuned for this weeks Planning Commission notes... probably after Wednesday as I have a midterm to study for.

Thursday, February 23, 2006

This a test

Ok, besides adding a bunch of nonsense to the first column in my template (tell me if it is a waste of time and I may get rid of it) I am trying out this new mac desktop widget to post this.

By the way, I want to thank everyone who gives a crap about what is going on in the city for reading this... knowledge is power

Tuesday, February 21, 2006

Live Blogging from the Cleveland Innerbelt Community Meeting

This is a first for me.
I am going to try and do a live blog.

We are at Myers University.

The room is packed.
Easily over 200 people.

Bob Brown is welcoming everyone.

9:15 am

Brown is giving us a primer on the what has happened over the past few years.
(It is good to see a nice turnout by the media)
Brown: "Our hope is that we can all learn from each other at todays meeting... keep open minds... have a safe innnerbelt for the next 50, or so years."

Introduces Jim Havilan, MidTown Cleveland, Inc.

9:20

Haviland: ODOT suggested that the public give there presentation before they do (by Gordon Proctor).
The importance of today's meeting.
-Well-defined issues
-Timing, The mayor wants a resolution
-The larger community must take a position

The goal of the meeting
-present outstanding points
-allow for informed decision making
-present a solution

9:25

History of Community Concerns in the Trench
(much of what is being said now is common knowledge for those who have been staying informed over the past few years; however it is good they are going over it)

History of Community Participation
Since December 2003, the community has maintained the need to keep Carnegie and Prospect access.
Many public meetings since then.
Jul 2005, ODOT rejects community position on trench.

9:30

History of Community Compromises
-St. Clair and Lakeside ramp closures
-West 14th and Abbey
-Innerbelt Bridge
-Quigley

Unresolved Community Points of Conflict (as of November, 2005)
-Removal of Carnegie Ave exit, eastbound
-Closure of Prospect entrance nad exit
-Close current Chester exit, westbound

9:35

Haviland walks us through ODOT's Alternative Trench Configuration (No payne Avenue Connection)
"We challange ODOT on how this is a better alternative."
Possible scenarios involving special events traffic, accidents, business location/relocation.

9:44

Procedural Points of Conflict
-Incomplete Economic Impact Study (marginal, at best)
-No traffic models

Acton requested by the Community
-Convene new series of Innerbelt Trench working meeting over a 60 day period to identify a design alternative that acheives an improved innerbelt without widespread economic and community damage.

Bob Brown introduces Gordon Proctor, Director of ODOT

9:48
He is talking about all of the projects that have been done by ODOT over the past few years.
Invite for a field trip to Columbus to observe a finished project.

Access and Crashes
-Central interchange is #1 for freeway crashes statewide
-787 crashes a year
-2 a day
-Annual cost of $12 million

"Not good for the people, not good for business."

-over a third of the accidents are during the afternoon rush
-1/3 are city residents
-1/3 are county residents

Shows a nice slide with an above ground view with little dots showing where the accidents have happened over the past three years (very impressive and convincing graphic)

9:57

Regarding Prospect and Carnegie ramps
"It is like trying to fix a sidewalk in an old neighborhood with many trees."
-Walker Weeks and Juvy Court, cannot be taken due to historic designation (legalality)
-Explains what is trying to be done in regards to accomidating I-77 north and Carnegie.
-Cannot look at those two ramps witout realizing how the rest of the interchange is impacted by the inclusion/exclusion of said ramps.

10:05
Introduces Craig Hebrebrand, project manager
"Comes down to this, five years we have worked with the city and the issue comes down to solving the Carnegie Curve area... is there a solution?"
-Walks us through the area again.
-Talks about the known bottlenecks from Metro Curve, up.
-The Carnegie Curve area needs to be cleaned up in order to service the the other traffic coming from 71, 77 and 90.
-Shows November, 2005 recomendations
--Split access at Payne/Chester
--Frontage road jogs at Prospect
--Frontage road ends at Carnegie

Proposed Refinements, February 2006
-Consolidated access at Chester Avenue
-Straighten Frontage Road at Prospect
-Extend Frontage Rd to Cedar Avenue

10:17

(It looks as if the Chester ramps will remain and be improved. Nice.)
Gloria Ferris is here and pointed out to Craig, that he avoided talking about the yellow sections of the graphic, which, of course, are the proposed takings.

Back to Proctor

They wanted to have a model available with computer animation showing traffic, but there were technical difficulties... they will provide later; perhaps place it on the website. (That will be helpful.)

Urban Design and Aesthetic Enhancements
-points out the vandal fencing, the color (gray) and lack of landscaping
-shows a slide of a bridge in Dublin, Ohio and the bridges in Newburgh Hts (77)
-states these bridges are more inviting
-shows bridge in Columbus, High Street (I-670). The city found devolper who then built structures on the bridge... retail.
-In regards to economic study: there has never been an economic study done before in Ohio... this will be the first.
-ODOT does not have a history of doing it... they are doing the best they can do.

Back to Craig about economic study

10:33

Access and Economics
-shows timing w/o Carnegie and Prospect ramps
--general increases overall... (small, but still and increase)
--"No significant change in overall employment."
---existing employment 30,000
---0.2% increase = 70 jobs

Influence of Opportunity Corridor
-the corridor will not influence traffic positively or negatively
-the further away from 55th and I490, the less influence

Rap-up by Proctor

Verification of Recommendation
-ODOT to review our recommendation
-FHWA to conduct "independent" review of ODOT's recommendation

10:42

Back to Brown for comments and questions by the public

They can be directed to anyone in the room
rules:
-identify yourself
-identify who you are directing the quesation to.
-three minutes
-only discussing the trench issues

KUCINCH REPRESENTATIVE (Marty Gelfand)
-Procedural question to proctor regarding impacts
-how can you explain no impact with all of the ramp closures
--Proctor: depends on wether DC will say there is a environmental or economic impact
-when does the process start?
--it started five years ago, the formal submittals should be this year

Gerry Martin, resident
-against closing Carnegie
-wants a promise that there will be no accidents on the side streets instead of the freeway
--Proctor:crashes go down about 30%
They have not begun to study I71 yet, there will be some consolidation

Ed "Citizen" Hauser
-Submitted 13 request regarding public process
-process has been changed dramatically
-public comment period is over, yet portions of the process continue
-specifically, the bridge
-we need the reports, then we can comment - then make decisions
-reopen the process
Proctor: your emails were so numerous and detailed... we will respond
-the process has been working - over 3oo meetings
-the southern allignment is vastly more complex
-the tie-ins will impact traffic greatly
-closures could last 2-4 years, Toledo
-once the bridge is done, other freeways will have to be closed periodically
-as part of the analysis and discussion, which has been entered in the public record, the northern allignment has the least amount of impact
-a design team has been picked, there will be a signature bridge
-the report you ask for does not exist in the format you request, it will come

Mike Cheslar, Cheslar Group
-The presentation was terrific
-shocked at the lack of economic impact understanding
-the one page questionere was lacking
-how is this going to effect on our businesses
Proctor: study will show what the traffic flow will be if there is a no-build and then show what the traffic is proposed, block by block, during construction
-there has been no study before, we are doing the best we can
Cheslar: will there be other studies?
Proctor:there is no current methodology existing off the shelf that we can follow
Cheslar: There studies all over the country that we developers use regularly
Proctor: Yes there is if you are involved in office building

Gloria Ferris, Old Brooklyn
-Comment about calling this "The Trench"
-happy to see Proctor addressed the visual aspect of this
-what gaurantee do we have that design/aesthetics will be done
Brown: The city will gaurantee that it will be addressed
-an aesthetic committee is being assembled to follow up on these issues
Ferris: what about the cost
Proctor: many of hte things will be done anyway, the cost to make them visually pleasing cost very little
-federal enhancemnet funds
-encourage NOACA to take part in these discussions

Robert Bostwick, architech
(missed the question)
something about the retaining walls
Proctor: we will share the cost in any widening/retaining wall issues
Bostwick: A sincere proposal will show that you are interested in the trees as well as the sidewalk
Proctor: are you aware of the Shoreway Project? blah, blah... ODOT has provided most of the funding for this and other local projects that do not make the freeway any better, show that we are offering goodwill, blah,blah
Bostwick: what can be done to the innerbelt to not only enhance safety, but help the local economy
-we should take Havilands suggestion to take a 60 day break to study this
-there other solutions that we have not thouhgt about yet
Applause

John (?), Blonderhome(?)
local business owner
-his employees use the innerbelt
how is the new setup going to save time for people from our location, 40th and propect
Craig: the savings are on overall trip
-there may be some waiting at traffic lights, but the overall savings from the innerbelt travel to local businesses will be decreased
John: I am suspicious of you numbers

Phil Pavarini, Tremont West Board Member
When will there be a meeting so the citizens can attend - evening
Brown: some of our most effective meetings have been in the neighborhoods, not the big ones like this
Craig: concurred, we will continue to listen
-FHWA will continue to listen
-we will have some more evening meetings

11:15

Jim Volk, Cleveland Indians
-appreciates this type of gathering and the local CDC efforts
-for the most part this is a good plan
-i would really like to take another look at 90... 40,00 fans, plus Quicken and theaters...
i think the current plan, although an improvemnet, is still flawed
-homeland security issues, do not see how this plan addresses this

Joe Cimperman, Coucilman
there has been six years of study plus w6 weeks of economic study, surprised to hear that this was your first
-when will it be done?
-who is going to pay for the maintainance of the marginal roads
-we ask that ODOT address that
-agrees with the 60 day cooling off period
-is there a concensus about this
-the conty may have some input about JUVY
Proctor: it is a given that we will do the 60 days... and up until the end of the year
- we have not maintained roads like this in the past, but will discuss with the city

Mark Leonard, Dodd Camera
-there needs to be an additional way to exit the freeway in case an exit is missed, otherwise you will end up on the other side of the river
-Juvy, questions the historic relevance of the building
Brown: it is not he use of the historic building, it is the architectual significance

Tom, Gateway
Discussed some historic issues with other buildings and preservation issues that have come up

Chris Bongorno, Planning Student
-concerned about the streetlevel traffic
-concerned about the possible 30 plus buildings that will be taken
---Artcraft
-these taking will hurt the image of the city
Brown: the city agrees that we have to do everything possible to make sure these building are saved
St. Clair/Superior: have asked ODOT to relook at some of the allignments issues with some of the buildings
Craig: We looked at takes conservatively
-there are some that we may not need
-some of the impact will only involve some of the parking lots associated with building

Frank Porter, Central Cadillac
-Greatful he has been involved with all discussions
-after spending all of the money we spent on remodeling... it will be more difficult for customers to reach us.
-compared this proposed closing to closing harvard/271 exits and trying to get to brainard
-to the representative from FHWA, is there rome for compromise
FHWA: (did not know he was here)
-this is the type of thinking we like to see... discussion
-is everyone going to get what they want, no
-in the end, this will be the most balanced
-there is room for compromise
-we cannot let special interest keep us from oour objectives: safety, access and congestion
-there is room for compromise, but we cannot promise Carnegie will remain open
Proctor: if we could keep these two exits open, we would. but the traffic studies and animation shows that traffic stops on the freeway when either one of these exits remain open
-the physics of it will not work
Jim Haviland:
-on the issue of compromise, we have proposed a a different configuration that would take Juvy , but allow for a better configuration
Proctor:
-we feel legally handtied by federal caselaw, if there is an alternative where there is no taking, then we have to follow through on that precident
-we are bound legally

Steve Qua, Limo Business
-it is not an issue of the amount of time it takes to get from a to b, it is the perception
-are those ramp reductions going to address this
-economic study question: will this allow for your business to grow?
-that question does not exist
-Can you organically grow, if the customer perceives that there is an negative change

Bill Beckenbach, Quadrangle
-concerned with the truck traffic as it effects tri-c, post office and hospital

John Cleff, Cleveland Clinic
-we are responsible for as much of the congestion as anybody
-it is important that we maintain a front door and a back door to our facility
-Euclid Corridor will reduce some of that access
-we are only to continue to grow, this must be realized

Ed Hauser
-back to public process
-i am looking for answers
-i take the lack of answers as an insult personally
-there is a 14 step public process that has been broken
FHWA: the person you need to reach is Kappka in DC
-I am aware of your concerns
-we are trying to address your concerns
-you asked about the documentation, we are addressing it
-the decisions are not final until we have finished going through the process
-the January deadline will be extended (wow)
-please do not feel like you are being ignored

Hauser:
-the bridge has been decided on and that is the part that has been decided on.
FHWA: that desicion has not been finalized (wow, again)

Terry , Business Owner
(missed question)
something about timeframe for property aquisition
Craig:
case by case until

Bob Brown:
Than you and good bye


(Comments anyone?)

Tuesday, February 07, 2006

Cleveland Planning Commission Report – Friday, February 3, 2006

Better late then never, right? I thought last semester was intense, whew… I have lot of reading to do. Anyway…


Call to order – 9:06 AM

Roll Call –

Present:
Bob Brown
Tony Coyne
Joe Cimperman
Lillian Kuri
Gloria Jean Pinkney

Absent:
David Bowen
Larry Lumpkin
Rev. S. Small

Mandatory Referrals (All approved)

  1. Ordinance #2210-05: City property on 5158 Broadway Avenue sold to Dr. Javier Lopez. Dr. Lopez says he will occupy 50% of the property and lease the other portion out. He also has plans for a second phase.
  2. Ordinance #119-06: The sale of Land Reutilization Program property located on Cedar Avenue, between East 100th and 101st Streets to Fairfax Renaissance Development Corporation. This land is for the Star Research Building that was conceptually approved by the commission last December. It was noted the Cleveland Clinic is still not on board with the developer; however, they said they do not need the Clinic in order to move forward. Good news.
  3. Ordinance #161-06: Amend a previously passed ordinance passed on October 31, 2005 regarding building height requirements within the Midtown Mixed Use District.

Summary Calendar (All approved)

  1. Ordinance #115-06: Authorized the sale of Land Reutilization Program property on East 68th Street to Juanmea Charnuse Harris.
  2. Ordinance #116-06: Authorized the sale of Land Reutilization Program property on Whittier Avenue to Angela Bennett.
  3. Ordinance #118-06: Authorized the sale of Land Reutilization Program property on St. Clair Avenue to Ronda J. Thompson.
  4. Ordinance #22-06: To vacate a portion of Alum Court
  5. Ordinance #17-06: To vacate a portion of the 1st un-named Alley, west of Pearl Road from Krather Road to its northern terminus.

Lot Split (Ward 12)
7732 Spafford Road

What should have been a routine approval was dragged on for nearly an hour. I am not going to get all of this correct, but I will try. The property either currently has or is proposed to have four units on it: three single-family and one multi-family – none of which would be owner occupied. Partly because of this and with issues regarding the legality of the current driveway ribbon (in addition to the lack of support from the local councilman) the commission did not approve the lot split.
It was suggested the owner, who was not present, might consider tearing one of the houses down and place (legal) driveway with a nice garage and carriage house in its place.

Quote of the day – Tony Coyne:

“Never let the market dictate a good planning decision.”

Buckeye Road Design Review, BR 2006-01

2780 East 116th Street, Gas Station, Hanini Sub and Corned Beef – Demolition and Reconstruction

This should have also been a relatively simple approval; however, the owner of the proposed gas station did not take well to the local development corp. committee’s comments about the project and instead of coming back to them with improvements, they went straight to the commission (with said improvements… or at least some of the).

What is planned is to tear down the existing structure and have it replaced with a new one. What was an issue had to do with landscaping and certain design elements (the business is located near Shaker Square and Metro Hospital), both of which were addressed.

In the end, the commission approved the plan with a condition that the existing guardrail along an adjacent side street is taken down and in its place, a decorative black aluminum fence along the entire street edge.

Mt. Pleasant BRD, Confirmation (approved)
Chandra Williams

Midtown Design Review, M2006-001 (approved)
BRD, Ward 7

4600 Euclid Avenue, New construction of 3-story office building & parking garage renovation, seeking full approval

Paul Volpe of City Architecture gave this presentation. Remember the multi-alarm fire at this location last April? (photo by Mike Whitiker, Firehouse.com) Well, a design has been submitted for a new office building to be built in that location. If you cannot picture the location, it is next to the Agora and across the street from the RTA Garage. Attempts to post the rendering were unfruitful. It will be a very nice addition to the street and will fit in well with the Euclid Corridor.

Design Review, DRC 06-004, (approved)

Wards 17 and 14
Stockyard Homes, LP., Lease Purchase Properties, Scattered Site Single-Family Houses

18 units of housing to be built on empty lots throughout the Stockyards Neighborhood. Three differmet models will be available.

Director’s Report (none)


Ed Hauser

At the January 6 Planning Commission meeting, Ed Hauser was cut short at the end of the meeting (regarding the Innerbelt Project) due to a previously scheduled flu shot event being held in the same room. Tony Coyne told Ed he could come back at another time to address the commission.

Today was his day. What follows are some of the comments made by some of the Commission members during this time.

Cimperman -
*Paul Alsenas brought the bridge alignment issue to the public’s attention.
*ODOT recently was part of a meeting with numerous politicians (not Paul Alsenas) and all came intoconsensus regarding the dropping of the southern alignment
*The Economic Development study still has not been done
*Perhaps we should invite Paul Alsenas to help with the economic development portion
*Mayor Jackson
wants all trench issues resolved before he endorses the alignment
*Avon Commons, Rockside and Chagrin Highlands would not exist without the current rampage system in place.

Coyne –
*He disagreed with Cimperman stating the creation of these places were circumstantial

Cimperman –
*ODOT Director Proctor told Mayor Jackson, “I just don’t understand the people of Cleveland.” *Cimperman then stated (to commission) He’s right, he does not understand us.
*All this time ODOT had been asking for us to compromise on very aspects of the freeway design repeatedly. We have been compromising for 5 ½ years.
*There are some major problems ahead with this project. Attention has been brought to the consultants and ODOT regarding the failing bulkheads on the Cuyahoga River – they never thought about it; Homeland Security – they never thought about that either.

Kuri –
*There was a 50 person scoping committee with no one person or agency being held accountable

Cimperman –
*The scoping Committee was designed to fail
*In June of 2004, ODOT said they would include community development with the project. *Sometime between then and June of 2005, something happened where they decided not to address it.
*There is a political feeling that we (Cleveland) will be ok with whatever is done with the trench because of the all of the work that was accomplished with the West Shoreway
*“You think they (ODOT) doesn’t get it… I think they do get it and are purposely avoiding it.”

Wednesday, February 01, 2006

St. Clair-Superior Dog Update

Some people asked me for more details on the dog art for the St. Clair - Superior neighborhood.
Here is some information from Katharyne Marcus, Commercial Development Manager for the local development corporation.
The white things with the bubble wrap on them are fiberglass dog sculptures that will be placed on steel boxes (making them 5 feet 5 inches tall) and scattered throughout the St. Clair Superior neighborhood.

This is a three fold project funded in part by the Cuyahoga County Commissioners:
1. Public art (local artists are implementing their own unique designs using the dog as their canvas),
2. Cultural awareness (2006 is the Chinese New Year - Year of the Dog) a,
3. Economic development (we anticipate that this project will bring in new customers to support our local businesses).
Each dog will be sponsored by a business or individual and on display from May through September. In October, the dogs will be up for auction. The proceeds from the auction will be seed money for next year - Year of the Boar.

Know anyone who would want to sponsor a dog? Tell them to call me at 881-0644.

Katharyne Marcus

Monday, January 30, 2006

The Cleveland Colectivo Considers Community Grant Requests

Clevelanders coming together to strengthen our community through collective investments that identify and nurture innovative projects.

Last Wednesday, a group of area residents that make up the Cleveland Colectivo, began to sift through nearly 50 requests for funding. (Pictures from the meeting.) These request ranged from environmental to arts to community building. At this meeting, the Colectivo cut the selection to 12 finalist and over the next week or so they will pick the final selections and the amount they will be awarded. Good luck to everyone.

What is the Cleveland Colectivo, you ask. The words from the website are much better then what I could come up with, so:
In the fall of 2004 a small circle of people decided it was time to stop talking about Cleveland’s problems and start investing in solutions. They gathered together friends and neighbors to begin building a new giving circle and The Cleveland Colectivo was born. Inspired by the traditional practice of immigrant neighbors who invested in each other’s businesses in order to build community, the Cleveland Colectivo is a group of like-minded friends, neighbors, and colleagues who have joined together for the purpose of collective giving.
If you want more information, or would like to join, visit the site - here.


Now for something completely different, these nearly life-size, bubble wrapped dogs will soon be the throughout the St. Clair - Superior Neighborhood sporting, I imagine, some funky colors. They will be given to local artists to paint, or whatever, and placed in various places in the neighborhood in recognition of, in part, the Chinese Lunar New Year which happens to be the Year of the Dog.



Finally, my post will be slowing down somewhat over the next three months due to heavy reading this semester in school. I will still post the happenings of the Planning Commission after their meetings - so stay tuned.


Friday, January 20, 2006

No Planning Commission Report Today

The little ones are home from school today and they get bored easily when I take them to a meeting. Hell, even I get bored.
Instead, I want to bring you up to speed on the workings of the Commission; that is, what is their mandate and how much control do they really have. I would like to eventually fill everyone in on who the members are, what do they do in real life, how long have they been on the commission and other bits of useful information I think everyone should know. This will be an ongoing project, so here is the first part.
The Planning Commission's website states on their on home page:
The City Planning Commission, established in 1915 (as the "City Plan Commission"), is a body of seven members, six are appointed by the Mayor and one is a member of City Council. The Commission is supported by a staff of professional planners and architects. The City Charter gives the Commission responsibility for preparing plans to guide "development and improvement" of the City and its neighborhoods, and for reviewing all legislation and other matters that concern the "use or development of land.”

Chapter 11 of the City Charter

§ 76 City Planning Commission

There shall be a City Planning Commission composed of seven (7) members. One shall be a member of the Council of the City of Cleveland chosen by each Council to serve during the term of such Council, and six members shall be appointed by the Mayor, with the approval of Council, and may be removed by him. The term of the members, other than Council members, shall be six (6) years, except that of the initial appointments, the terms of two members shall be two (2) years, and the terms of two members shall be four (4) years. Vacancies in the Commission shall be filled in the same manner for the unexpired term. The Chairman of the Commission shall be appointed annually by the Mayor from the members and may be removed as Chairman at his pleasure.
(Effective November 21, 1967)

§ 76-1 Directors and Staff

There shall be a Planning Director who shall be nominated by the Commission and appointed by the Mayor at his discretion. He shall be ex-officio Secretary of the City Planning Commission and shall serve until removed by the Mayor with the concurrence of a majority of the Commission. Upon nomination of the Planning Director the Commission shall appoint as its staff such technical and office personnel and assistants as it may deem necessary within the appropriation made available for such purpose. All such appointments, except the Planning Director and his secretary, shall be made in conformity with the civil service provisions of this Charter. Under the direction of the Commission the Director shall supervise and control the planning staff.
(Effective November 3, 1942)

§ 76-2 Powers and Duties of Commission

It shall be the function and duty of the Planning Commission to make and adopt a general plan for the development and improvement of the City, and for any area outside of the City which in the judgment of the Commission bears relation to the planning of the City. No general plan or portions thereof or amendments thereto shall be adopted by the Commission until after a public hearing thereon. So much of the general plan as may be established or from time to time amended by ordinance of Council shall constitute the official map of the City of Cleveland. The Commission shall also make plans and proposals for specific improvements and projects which it deems desirable for the City and its surrounding area and recommend them to the appropriate authority. These plans and proposals shall not become a part of the general plan until adopted as such. The Commission shall have authority to call upon officers and employees of other departments and divisions of the City of Cleveland for assistance in City planning. On or before the 1st day of June in each year the Commission shall recommend to the Mayor a capital improvement budget for the following year and a comprehensive five-year capital improvement program. It shall be the duty of the Commission to take the initiative in planning for the City and surrounding area and it shall have full power to publish and distribute at public expense copies of plans or reports and to promote public interest in and understanding of general plans and of other recommendations or proposals. It shall have authority to make such investigations, maps and studies relating to the planning of the community as it may deem desirable. The Planning Commission may recommend to the appropriate public authorities or private agencies programs for the development and improvement of the community, for the enactment of legislation pertaining thereto, for the building of public structures and improvements and for the financing thereof. The Commission may enter into agreement with other governmental or private agencies necessary or desirable for carrying forward any of its purposes subject to the approval of Council.
(Effective November 3, 1942)

The members consist of :

Anthony J. Coyne, Chairman
Attorney, Mansour, Gavin, Gerlack & Manos Tony specializes in municipal planning and zoning law and general litigation. He is a housing and neighborhood activist as well as a board member of the Near West Housing Corporation. He is credited with providing a professional services link to the Ohio City neighborhood group that provides housing for low and moderate-income families. In 1989, Tony served on Mayor Michael White's "Transition '90" team and was subsequently appointed to the Cleveland Planning Commission. Tony's membership in professional and public service organization include the Cleveland Bicentennial Commission Advisory Board, the Citizens League of Greater Cleveland, the Board of Trustees of the Ohio Planning Conference, and the Cleveland Planning Commission. (From Maxine Goodman-Levin College of Urban Affairs)

David H. Bowen
Architect, Richard L. Bowen + Associates
Lillian Kuri
Former Executive Director, Cleveland Public Art
Lawrence A. Lumpkin
Former School Board President, Cleveland Public School District
Gloria Jean Pinkney

City of Cleveland Councilman, Ward 13, Joe Cimperman

Rev. Sam E. Small

Secretery, Robert N. Brown (Current Planning Director)

Thursday, January 19, 2006

What You Missed at the Webloggers Meetup on Wednesday

Last night, the Cleveland Webloggers met once again at the Town Fryer on St. Clair Avenue. There are some good events coming up and I learned a few things too.

First, if you are an attention freak and you want people to read what you have to say, just mention Tim Russo's name (we will see what happens).

Next, if you are looking for more attention, then comment about something from The Washington Post, like this article, which brings up the ongoing problem of people believing their cell phone numbers will soon be made available to telemarketers. In case you are one of those people, it is illegal for telemarketers to make unsolicited calls to a cell phone. Somebody at school was just expressing his concern to me over this afternoon. (If you are still worried, go here.)

The big question of the night was when, if ever, Lori was going to post again. Apparently, she has been busy making college student's financial situation worse buy single-handedly raising the cost of textbooks around the world.

Among the 20 or so people there, was Stu Kollar whose new blog, Writeup, may be one of the only admittedly ‘fictional’ blogs around.
From his description:

“Writeup contains some of my fiction, a little of which has been published but most of which has not. It gives me an easy way to offer a look at stuff I've written over the years, including a few short stories and opening chapters of longer pieces. Anyone interested in seeing more can get it by posting an e-mail request.”
Check it out.

Will Kessel asked how many blogs in the sphere are fictional and somebody from the back yelled “All of them!” I think it was Jeff Hess.

Get The Book!

Politry 2005

Since my mother doesn’t have a computer, I compiled Politry for 2005 in a chapbook: 2005, a Bad Year Made Verse, – 317 “poems,” mostly about stuff Bush bungled – a chronicle of a crummy year or a great gag gift for a conservative friend. 132 pages, saddle stitched, $9.50, including postage.

Also present were Roger Bundy from Cleveland Equanimous Philosopher, Jack, Gloria and Ken Duncan who was a little taken aback at the prospect of peddling his book, Politry for 2005: A Bad Year Made Verse. You can pick yours up by sending an email to book@politry.com.

Reader, (as opposed to writer) Mary Ellen from the Cleveland Public Library was there and wanted to let everyone know about the possibility of holding a Cleveland Webloggers event in the Eastman Garden during iNGENUiTY this summer – strictly for fertilization purposes, of course.

Wrapping up the attendance were Danielle, George, Peter, Molly, Mary Beth and Pho, who promises to have a joint Akron/Cleveland Webloggers Meetup soon. There were others present, but I either did not actually talk with them, I could not write fast enough or they left before we finally got around to the traditional introductions.

As for the actual meeting portion, Danielle talked about the upcoming Meet the Bloggers Fundraiser at the Pearl of the Orient restaurant next Thursday. You can read more about this here… or at Plugged In Cleveland. If you are not sure whether or not you want to go this event, word has it George will have on his kilt… something about not having a female to assist him like the other celebrity bartenders. The discussion then went into how to expand the Meet the Bloggers concept to individuals who touch the lives of ordinary people.

Overall, it was a very good meeting; however, that is subjective since this was the first time I came to a meeting from the beginning instead of showing up at the end. If I missed some of the details, tough. At least I stayed sober enough to take some notes

Saturday, January 14, 2006

A Comment on Urban Ohio's Forum: "Building 'Pesht' - Cleveland Megaproject"

As mentioned on the Cuyahoga County Weblog, Ken Prendergast has just completed his three part series on developer Bob Stark's vision for downtown Cleveland in the Sun News.
From the County Weblog
The West Side Sun News concludes its three-part series on developer Robert Stark's downtown Cleveland plans with a look at ideas for accelerating the Port Authority's proposed relocation across the Cuyahoga River from the 50 year concept in the City's Lakefront Plan.
If you have not read the articles, do it now. Or, go to the forum instead. You can get some good backround information provided by Ken as well as some interesting opinions by many others. Currently, there is a discussion on what the new neighborhood north of the Warehouse District should be called. What would you call it?






Thursday, January 12, 2006

Cleveland's Own Modern Day Ghost Town

As I previously reported , the movers are busy removing the last of the residents out of the Jefferson Neighborhood so they can start on demolition later this month for the Ryser Properties shopping center. I drove around yesterday to take pictures of the current condidtions. What follows are three out of the twenty five I took.
If you would like to see the whole set, including the original color shots, go here.




Monday, January 09, 2006

Cleveland Planning Commision Report - Friday, January 6, 2006

This sucks, I had to completely retype this post because I am an idiot.

I wish I had thought of this sooner – for now on, when reporting the happenings from the Planning Commission Meeting, I will include a rooster of attendees. After attending these meetings for the better part of three years, I have noticed there are many times when certain members are not there; that is, there are at least two members who are rarely there. Seeing as this is a compensated position, which includes parking, you would think that most of the members would be there a majority of the time. I have a problem with this. At a later posting, after doing some research, I will describe the details of how a member is appointed and what the expectations are to be of them, as well as there compensation.
On with the meeting

Mandatory Referrals (All Approved)
  1. An amendment to a previously passed ordinance regarding zoning of parcels on the west side of West 117th Street between Western Avenue and I-90
  2. Issuing a permit to allow Medical Mutual to install planter boxes, Planting beds and other streetscape obstructions
  3. Allowing Green Energy Ohio to lease space on the Kirtland Intake Crib for the purpose of conducting a wind study and maintaining a wind-monitoring tower for a two-year period. The city of Cleveland will receive the equipment after the two year study
  4. Determining the construction and installation of manually controlled pumps and equipment at the Nottingham Plant
  5. Authorizing the sale of property from the Land Reutilization Program to the Cleveland Public School District at East 146th and 147th Streets
  6. Demolition of the Trinity Building at 9203 Detroit Avenue, including asbestos abatement and remediation of the soil and groundwater at the site (This will the first major addition to the city’s Industrial Landbank Program in almost a year).
  7. [Added to the agenda] Rename a portion of Erieside Street behind the Great Lakes Science Center to Mather Way (pictured - lower half of image, source Google.)
Summary Calendar (all approved)
  1. Authorizing the sale of property on Marvin Avenue to Civic Builders as part of the Land Reutilization Program
  2. Authorizing the sale of city-owned property in Wade Park on East Boulevard to the United States Department of Veteran Affairs
  3. An addendum to a previously passed ordinance relating to the reconstruction of Jennings road (which, incidentally, began today)
  4. An amendment to a previously passed ordinance relating to the widening of West 150th street between Industrial Parkway and Brookpark Road
  5. Vacate a portion of Holmden Road (this will be used as a staging area for construction of Steel Yard Commons and Quigley Road)
Design Review
  1. Ohio & Erie Canal Signage Program, Conceptual Review – The signs (conceptual renderings pictured) designed by Cloud Gehshan Associates, will replace the fading signs that currently exist throughout the corridor. The Ohio & Erie National Canalway name will be changed to the Ohio & Erie Canalway. This falls within new guidelines created by the Feds who are changing all references to “Scenic Byway” to America’s Byway.” Apparently, many travelers are confused by the ‘scenic’ designation when driving through urban areas like the area near the Main Post Office. This was approved with a recommendation to add the website address to the bottom of the signs.
  2. Demolition and Parking Lot Design of the former Saint John’s Dormitory (1964) at 1100 Rockwell Avenue
Special Presentation – Little Italy Master Plan
The PD article by Tom Breckenridge does a much better job then I ever could describing the nuances of the plan. The Little Italy Master Plan, although not the first neighborhood plan to be brought before the commission, is diffidently the most comprehensive neighborhood plan ever brought to the board for approval. The plan was approved with the highest of commendation.

Directors Report
Director Bob Brown happily stated that he was sworn in as Mayor Jackson’ Director of the Planning Commission Monday, January 2.
He mentioned there was a good possibility that the planning functions of the city’s Neighborhood Development Department may be merged with the Planning Commission. A move I am surprised has not happened sooner.
Mentioned that ODOT’s perceived gesture of goodwill by having national experts look at the southern alignment option of the Innerbelt Plan was not as it seemed. Apparently, these experts would have had to make a recommendation on the plan anyway. Regardless, I hope they give it a fair look.

Wednesday, January 04, 2006

Nearly $18 Million Spent on Avoiding Eminent Domain for Ryser Project

File under public disclosure.

My wife likes to read the real estate section of the PD on Saturdays. This way she can keep up on housing values in the neighborhood. In this past Saturday's issue, she noticed something peculiar – dozens of house all on the same street had been transferred from one property owner to another. Then she noticed it was ore then one street – in fact, there were five streets with no less then 65 properties listed. (Over 100 properties were purchased.)

The total amount paid for the properties listed is around $12,875,882. In total, Ryser Properties is said to have paid almost $18 million for all of the properties. This was done with help of a loan of $6 million from the city, which Target will pay back to the city with taxes generated.

I figured out right away the listings being shown were the parcels being used for the new Ryser Properties shopping center featuring a Giant Eagle and Target store on West 117th Street, north of I-90. I’ve driven around this neighborhood a few times over the past couple of months. It is very strange seeing all of the houses boarded up throughout the area - a modern day ghost town, if you will. Most of the tenants are to be moved out by the end of this month and demolition is to begin right away. Target plans to be opened by October of this year (2006). (There is no mention of this project on Ryser's website.)

From the listing in the paper and with help from county auditor information, it appears Target has paid the most for a piece of property. That would be the parcel located 11826 Elmwood Avenue that was purchased for $2,119,022. Not bad for a 5,000 sq ft property that sold for $33,000 in 1983. That’s over $423 a square foot.

The top five are listed as follows:

11826 Elmwood Avenue - $2,119,022;
3105 West 121st Street - $1,000,000;
11916 Elmwood Avenue – $400,000;
11839 Sector Avenue - $305,000; and
11933 Sector Avenue - $225,000.

The bottom five include:

12024 Sector Avenue - $35,000;
11810 Belmont Avenue - $45,000;
12012 Sector Avenue - $55,000;
12004 Sector Avenue - $80,000; and
3106 West 120th street - $80,000.

Keep in mind, the developers paid an additional 30% over market value to the owners so there would not be any use of eminent domain. Just goes to show, everyone has their price – some more then others... and some les.